What To Do with the Doghouse When Fido Dies

In Facebook's "Richardson Urban and Neighborhood Discussions", Andrew Laska shared an announcement by the City of Richardson about open houses to gather community feedback about the City Hall/Comp Plans. He offered his own priorities, the first one (two?) of which were "1) Legalize missing middle housing. 1a) Legalize ADUs."

---

Former Richardson City Councilperson Janet DePuy commented, "Watch out for unintended consequences of allowing all ADUs. There's much to consider on this issue...parking, privacy, lot size, utilities, etc." So I asked her to briefly list the pros and cons of ADUs, as she sees them. She quickly replied, listing several things that need to be taken into consideration. Nothing wrong with her list. Then I thought to ask ChatGPT for its own list of pros and cons. ChatGPT even more quickly replied with a longer list (that's the power of today's AI). The list is not specific to Richardson (that's the limitation of today's AI, and to be fair, neither was DePuy's list), but for a generic list of pros and cons, it's not bad, in my opinion. But it did miss one obvious "pro" for ADUs: "Provides an option for a new use for Fido's old doghouse."

Here's my conversation with ChatGPT:

The Wheel: List ten pros and ten cons of rezoning cities to allow for ADUs (accessory dwelling units).

ChatGPT:

Sure! Here are ten pros and ten cons of rezoning cities to allow for Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs):

Pros:

1. Increased housing supply: ADUs provide an opportunity to increase housing stock within existing neighborhoods, addressing housing shortages and increasing affordability.
2. Affordable housing options: ADUs offer relatively affordable housing options, allowing homeowners to generate rental income or accommodate extended family members, students, or elderly relatives.
3. Aging in place: ADUs enable aging homeowners to downsize or have additional income without leaving their neighborhoods, promoting community continuity.
4. Diverse housing types: ADUs introduce a variety of housing types, including basement apartments, backyard cottages, and garage conversions, diversifying the architectural fabric of neighborhoods.
5. Sustainable development: ADUs promote more efficient land use by utilizing existing infrastructure and reducing urban sprawl.
6. Increased property values: ADUs can enhance property values and potentially boost neighborhood aesthetics and desirability.
7. Community integration: ADUs foster multigenerational and diverse communities, supporting social interactions and increased connections among residents.
8. Income generation: ADUs allow homeowners to generate rental income, providing financial stability and opportunities for wealth accumulation.
9. Flexible living arrangements: ADUs provide flexible living arrangements for homeowners, accommodating changing needs or temporary housing for guests or caregivers.
10. Utilization of underutilized space: ADUs make use of underutilized spaces like basements, garages, or unused sections of the property, optimizing land utilization.

Cons:

1. Increased density and congestion: ADUs can lead to increased population density, potentially straining infrastructure, parking availability, and public services.
2. Reduced privacy: ADUs may impact privacy for homeowners and neighbors, especially if the units overlook or encroach on neighboring properties.
3. Neighborhood character: ADUs can alter the character and aesthetics of neighborhoods, potentially changing the scale and density of existing housing.
4. Parking challenges: ADUs often require additional parking, which can exacerbate parking shortages in areas with limited spaces available.
5. Strain on infrastructure: Increased housing density may strain existing infrastructure, including water, sewage, electricity, and public transportation systems.
6. Zoning compliance and regulation: Implementing and enforcing zoning regulations for ADUs can be challenging and require additional resources and administrative oversight.
7. Limited oversight: ADUs may result in additional rental units, which can be difficult to regulate and monitor for compliance with safety and rental regulations.
8. Potential for speculative investment: ADUs may attract speculative investors, leading to increased property prices and potentially displacing long-time residents.
9. Unequal distribution: Rezoning for ADUs may not be evenly distributed across neighborhoods, leading to imbalances in housing availability and exacerbating existing inequalities.
10. Opposition from residents: Some homeowners may oppose ADUs due to concerns about increased noise, decreased property values, or perceived impacts on neighborhood aesthetics and quality of life.

It's important to note that the pros and cons can vary depending on the specific context, local regulations, and community dynamics.

Source: ChatGPT.

---

"From doghouse to home,
Small dwelling, cozy abode,
ADUs welcome."
— h/t ChatGPT